
Now that we've read all the books and seen all the movies, we Harry Potter fans no longer share that sweet anticipatory pleasure of speculating what will happen next. However, there's still plenty of fun to be had with J.K. Rowling's characters and the world she created for them to inhabit. For those who aren't about to hop on the plane to visit Orlando's Wizarding World theme park, there are simpler pleasures, like
The Unofficial Harry Potter Sweet Shoppe Kit. When I was offered a sample to test, I wasn't sure whether to say "You had me at Harry Potter" or "You had me at Sweet Shoppe Kit".
The cover of the box says the kit's appropriate for ages 8 and up, so last Saturday I got together with my nine-year-old niece Tara and my stepdaughter Niamh, who's in her early twenties, to try it out. The Harry Potter connection was more or less lost on Tara, who's still two years younger than Harry was at the beginning of the first book (she has a great treat in store for her later). However, the box wowed her; it's made of satisfyingly solid cardboard with an attractive brass-bound corner look.
There are two layers inside, and the top one displays the most important component:
The Unofficial Harry Potter Sweet Shoppe Book by Dinah Bucholz. There's also a mold for making chocolate frogs, brooms, bugs and owls, a collection of nice-looking reusable plastic "broomsticks" for the chocolate broom pops, and about 15 cello bags and ribbon ties for packaging the treats. There's enough extra space in the box to store ingredients, like chocolate pellets or candy decorations.
Looking over the recipes, Tara was attracted to the one for sugar mice (as served at Honeydukes, the Hogsmeade confectioner's shop). I thought it seemed like a good choice for a nine-year-old, because it required no cooking and called for only four common ingredients: confectioner's sugar, butter, vanilla and corn syrup.
Niamh, who, like me, is enough of a Harry Potter fan to have bought books at midnight on the release dates and attended some of the movies on their opening days, was most keen on the chocolate frogs because - as she pointed out - discovering the chocolate frogs from the trolley on the Hogwarts Express was one of Harry's first happy magical experiences, and they were connected with his first meeting with Ron and Hermione. I pointed out that the ones we made probably wouldn't hop. She seemed resigned to this.
We concocted the sugar mice first, and it was immediately clear that the recipe instructions were not written for a nine-year-old. Tara's a good reader for her level, and she knew "confectioner's sugar", but had trouble with words like "indentations" and "consistency". I noted that there was no mention of the tools that would be needed for the job. Still, we assembled the ingredients mainly from her following of the directions, and she only needed a little help combining things. We fridged the mouse mix and set to work on the chocolate while the mixture was cooling to a workable "consistency".

Here, I'm sorry to have to point out that Bucholz and her editors have permitted at least one serious error to creep into the text, a bad enough one to spoil the half-dozen or so recipes that call for melted chocolate. The chocolate tempering instructions say to melt chocolate in a double boiler "until the temperature reaches 220°F for dark chocolate or 110°F for milk or white chocolate". Apart from the question as to whether you can heat anything above 212°F in a double boiler (because it ought not to be able to get hotter than boiling water), the correct temperature for dark chocolate is 120°F. I don't know what happens to chocolate at 220°F, but I can't imagine it's anything good.

Luckily, I've taken a couple of chocolate classes, so I caught the typo. However, I think Niamh, who's a very able cook, would have been led astray. Again, some mention of tools would have been useful, since it's extremely hard to skim excess chocolate off a mold without an offset spatula (as in the photo above). On the other hand, after I tempered the chocolate, Tara had a very good time spooning it into the molds provided, and when it hardened, the nine shapes popped out very neatly.
I was quite taken with the chocolate brooms on their plastic broomsticks, and the frogs looked really good. After Tara bagged and ribboned the chocolates, the family members she gave them to were really impressed with the results. "Did you really make these?" they asked. "We molded them," she replied proudly.

But back to the mice: when we started to work with the refrigerated mouse mixture, it was very, very tricky to follow the directions to make satisfying mice. Niamh bowed out early. Mine looked like polar bears, cats, hamsters, hippos, and in one case a gravely ill rat. At this point, Niamh's roommate, a trained pastrychef, poked his nose in. "Making fondant from scratch?" he asked. "Oh, man!" ...and promptly disappeared. You have to feel a little anxious about a kids' recipe that scares a grownup with pastry papers.
However, alone of all of us, Tara managed to make pretty convincing mice. She had fun doing it, she loved the taste of the mouse dough (which she kept dipping into), and she was really proud of the results. She also loved the squdgey feel of the fondant, and was with difficulty persuaded to stop squeezing the bag of leftover dough - and at that only after the first freezer bag had sprung so many leaks it had to be double bagged.
The five at right are Tara's mice. The two at the back seems to be a cat and a very sad rat. The lump with eyes at left is either Jabba the Hut or the unused mouse dough.Of the 35 recipes in the book, 10 call for an ice cream maker, at least three call for special-order ingredients like citric acid and invertase, and many call for boiling sugar to precise temperatures. There are a few simpler things, like a list of ice cream sundae variations, hot chocolate and a very tasty looking frozen lemon pop. But in the final analysis, I think it's inaccurate to call this a child's cooking kit.
I see that
The Unofficial Harry Potter Sweet Shoppe Kit retails around $25, with discounts through some of the online retailers. At that price (and apart from the chocolate gaffe), this is a pretty good beginner's guide to basic confectionery; it also covers boiled fudge, marshmallows, nougat and hard candies (no recipe for many-flavoured beans, though).
I think the kit would be great for 18- to 24-year old Potter fans who are also kitchen geeks, or for the parent with spare time who's comfortable engineering some fairly complex cooking manoeuvres with their child in such a way that the child feels empowered rather than overwhelmed. And I'm not exactly the target audience, but I do feel somewhat inspired by the initial experiment to try further recipes in the book myself.
Now if only someone with a working wand could just wave it and say "
typo reparum!"
The second photo was taken by me; thanks to Niamh Malcolm for all the rest!