
I don't consider myself much of a tropical fruit girl; I blame it on 300-plus years of North American genetics. However, I'm always ready to find out more about fruits and vegetables, so, following from my
apple-tasting adventure of February, I gathered a few friends together and embarked on a modest comparison of several different types of mangoes today.
Apparently, there are hundreds of different types of mangoes grown in
more than 30 countries – almost everywhere except Canada and northern Europe, actually. Some areas have their own local specialty, while some varieties have been adopted by commercial growers in many countries because they make successful crops for large-scale production. Not too surprisngly, India grows the most different types of mangoes.
Here in Toronto, a mango lover needs to keep an eye on the store shelves to find a diversity of mangoes; some smaller Asian and South Asian shops (like my local Gerrard Street grocers) import a wider variety than you'd find at the average supermarket. (By the way, there's a lot of useful information about how to judge ripeness, how to store and how to cook with mangoes at the
National Mango Board website.)

A few days ago, I received a big cardboard box containing three varieties of Mexican mangoes, courtesy of National Produce and the kind folks at Faye Clack Communications. I supplemented this bounty with a sample of India's Alfonso, which is apparently the go-to mango for making lassi. The bowl at the top contains the three Mexican mangoes. The biggest is Tommy Atkins; the medium-sized red and green one is Haden, and the small yellow one is Ataulfo.
In the platter above, the golden-orange fruit at the top right is Tommy Atkins; Haden is the greenish yellow below it, and Ataulfo is the yellow one to the left. The Indian Alfonso was small, yellow and quite round. This was the challenge that met Bev (@BevW on Twitter, who has already posted her reactions at her
Daily Bread Blog), Jennifer (@JenniferBylok), Mark (@MarkBylok) and Andrea (@TOfoodie).
A mango cutter was included in our kit; you can just see the edge of it at the top of the platter. I tried it on three different sizes of fruit, and found it worked best on the biggest. However, it was tricky to get it to bite into the mango skin to start, it tended to get caught around the big mango seed, and it left a lot of flesh on the seed with the smaller varieties. I prefer a knife, and it's nice to eat mangos right off the skin by cutting them in half, separating the pit, scoring the flesh into cubes and then
turning the mango half inside-out so you can bite the squares off the skin. Some of the mangoes on the platter are prepared that way.
For chopping them up, Bev (who has spent quite a bit of time in Trinidad, where Julie mangoes are popular) suggests slicing the fruit in thirds lengthwise, with the stone in the middle slice; then you just peel and slice.
We were also sent most of the makings for a
Mango Caprese Salad: basil and buffalo mozzarella, to which I added sea salt, cracked pepper and olive oil. As a lover of the classic tomato-based Caprese salad, I was skeptical; however, I had to agree with the member of our panel who declared it "surprisingly amazing". At least one of the group left with plans to replicate it at home right away.
Here are my notes on the various types we tried, in reverse alphabetical order:
- Tommy Atkins: Big and impressive, with orange flesh, but pulpier and blander than the other three. In reading about it later, I was not surprised to find that it's a popular choice for commercial growers because it's showy on the fruit stand and ships well; however, it's not the tastiest. The Red Delicious of the mango world, apparently.
- Haden: Tart, firm, a pretty yellow-green inside, and with what I think of as the most mango-ish taste of the four we sampled.
- Ataulfo: Pleasanty acidic and citrusy, with buttery yellow flesh, and the best in the salad.
- Alfonso: The Indian mango tasted very different, much more fragrant and flowery, not tart at all, with saffron-gold flesh and a pleasing custardy texture. I didn't think its taste was as "mango-y" as the Haden, but I really liked it, and thought it left almost a hint of coconutiness in the mouth.
Having tried the comparison, I certainly feel as though I've overlooked mangoes in the past – perhaps because I didn't know how to pick them out when they were ripe, or because I had sampled varieties that I didn't like – and I plan to try more. I'll look out for other Mexican varieties as they come into season, like Kent, Keitt and Francis, and I'll taste some of the Indian mangoes that will be turning up on Gerrard Street.
Above all, if my continuing experiments with fruit are telling me anything, it's that people who care about food probably have to let the commercial growers know that we really want produce that tastes good and is good for us; not just the items that stand up best to international shipping and long storage, and look most majestic in our shopping carts. If we don't get to try some of the lesser-known types of fruits and vegetables, we may miss out on discovering just how good they can be.